Showing posts with label 1955 Topps. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 1955 Topps. Show all posts

Apr 12, 2015

The Battle for the Soul of 1955

Imagine being a child 60 years ago. Life could have been good in the summertime. Every day morning, you'd wake up, have a breakfast of champions, go to the general store for some candy and cards on the 5 cent weekly allowance, and then flip and trade and go tire rolling or bike riding until the sun went down.

 It's how I picture it anyway.....in sepia tones with a shadow gradient.

But the best part of being a child in 1955, is that there were two card companies going all out to clamor for attention.  Bowman had staked its claim as the futuristic set in 1955 with the well-known color TV design while Topps had decided to go back to the future by turning its 1954 set 90 degrees to a horizontal presentation.

The reason why there was a choice was because players signed exclusives with each of the companies, not creating true parity in competition.  Design is only one part of the collecting experience; player collection is the other....you want to get the players you want...especially that fit your collection.

For Phillies fans and collectors, there were 19 cards in the 1955 Bowman set, including team favorites and stars, Del Ennis, Richie Ashburn, Robin Roberts, and Willie Jones.

By contrast, the 1955 team set had 10 cards with very little overlap.  Instead, the collectors had to be content with non-stars and less favorites such as:
Ted Kazanski: a 20 year old back-up infielder.
Thornton Kipper: a 25 year old relief pitcher with a total of 31 games pitched.
Danny Schell: a 26 year old pinch hitter extraordinaire.

Probably the best known name on the Phillies Topps checklist was Bob Miller, so what is a team collector to do?  I guess the only option really was to convert to a Topps rookie collector and try for a Clemente and Koufax.....how tragic.

Jun 18, 2012

Some Graded Vintage Phillies Courtesy of the Adventures of Napkin Doon

This was a group of one of the cooler sets of cards I've received in a trade.  This trade was courtesy of the proprietor of the blog with the never ending checklist chipaway (seriously, check out the awesomely organized wantlist spreadsheet) The Adventures of Napkin Doon.

He was jonesin' for some cards from the GQ, premiere edition and he offered up this triplet of tectonic titans of the vintage Phillies variety.    Before this, I had only three 1955 Topps cards in my collection, so they were very welcome additions/
Tom Casagrande (or Tom Big House) was graded a 4 VG-EX and never appeared in the majors, spending 7 years in the minors shuttling between the Philadelphia, Boston, and Washington systems.  He did play on three AAA teams.
Bob Miller was also graded a 4 VG-EX and by 1955 was a reliever after his glory days of mostly starting for the 1950 team.  He was 5th in the league in wins probability added in 1955, meaning he was used in a lot of high leverage situations and succeeded in them.
Mayo Smith was graded a VG 3 and was the manager of the Phillies from 1955-1958 compiling 164-282 record.  He's best known for managing the Tigers to the World Series title in 1968, making the unorthodox decision to start his all-season centerfielder (Mickey Stanley) at shortstop during the series over the Ray Oyler and to form a power hitting outfield of Jim Northrup, Willie Horton, and Al Kaline.  Kaline had been hurt most of the end of the season and needed to be worked into the lineup somehow without sacrificing too much defense ,so he transferred his centerfielder without an error all season to shortstop for 7 games (because the SS hit .135 for the season).

thanks for the trade!

Side note: 4 spots still available in the group break of the moment.